Skip to the page

Fasting

How to start intermittent fasting gently: the overnight gap

By Carol Pocock11 minute read

Ink and watercolor sketch of a bowl of lentils, greens and roasted squash with a wooden spoon, a linen napkin and a small jug.

If you want to know how to start intermittent fasting, start smaller than you think. Finish your dinner, close the kitchen, and eat nothing more until breakfast, so that about twelve hours pass between your last bite and your first. Keep that up for a few weeks, and only then, if it suits you and your doctor agrees, try a slightly shorter eating window.

Right Fasting is the sixth of the seven petals of the Starflower, the method at the heart of my book, Lifetime Body by Design. Each petal is what I call a Right Action, one of seven everyday practices that together build a foundation of health, and the stem that holds them up is habit.

I am a wellness coach and a yoga teacher, and I have eaten whole-food, plant-based for about thirty years. Before the habits stuck, I spent years yo-yo dieting, and I know how easily any rule about food can turn into another stick to beat yourself with. So the version of fasting I teach is the gentle one. It is about rhythm and rest for the body, and it should never feel like punishment.

Before you start: who should not fast without medical advice

Please read this part first. Intermittent fasting is not right for everyone, and some people should not try any form of it without their doctor's advice. That includes anyone who is:

  • pregnant or breastfeeding
  • under eighteen
  • underweight
  • living with, or recovering from, disordered eating of any kind
  • living with diabetes, or taking medicine that affects blood sugar
  • taking medicine that affects blood pressure
  • taking any medicine that needs to be taken with food or at set times

If you have any ongoing health condition, or you take regular medication, speak to your doctor before you change when you eat, even in the mild ways I describe here. A doctor or registered dietitian who knows you is the right person to say whether this suits you.

It is also worth saying plainly that research on intermittent fasting is still developing. Some studies suggest that eating within a regular daily window may help some people, and others find it makes little difference compared with simply eating well. We do not yet know a great deal about its long-term effects. I share this practice because it suits me and many people I work with, not because it is proven to be right for you.

What I mean by Right Fasting

In my book I describe Right Fasting as "the practice of intentional absence." In plain terms, it means giving your body regular stretches of time when it is not digesting anything, and choosing those stretches on purpose instead of grazing from morning to night.

Many of us never go more than a few hours without eating, and we treat a little hunger as a problem to fix at once. Right Fasting asks you to notice that pattern and loosen it. In its mildest form, which is the only form I am writing about here, it has three steps:

  1. Stop eating after dinner.
  2. Keep a twelve-hour overnight gap.
  3. Possibly, later, a slightly shorter eating window, if it suits you and your doctor agrees.

Most people find that the first two steps are enough. There is no prize for going further.

Step one: stop eating after dinner

This is the easiest place to begin because, for most of us, the evening is where the extra eating lives. It is rarely hunger. It is the end of a long day, the television, a habit of something sweet with a cup of tea.

So the first step is simple: when dinner is finished, the kitchen is closed. You can still have water or a cup of herbal tea. You just stop eating until morning.

A few things make this easier:

  • Make dinner a proper meal. If dinner is small, you will be hungry by nine o'clock. A plate with beans, lentils or tofu, plenty of vegetables and a whole grain will carry you much further.
  • Mark the end of eating. Wash up, wipe the counter, turn off the kitchen light, or brush your teeth early.
  • Keep the evening snacks out of the house. If they are not in the cupboard, the decision is already made.

If you would like help with the snacking side of this, I have written a separate piece on how to stop snacking between meals, which is really the first step of this petal.

Step two: the twelve-hour overnight gap

Once the kitchen closes after dinner without much fuss, look at the clock. If you finish dinner at seven and have breakfast at seven, you already have a twelve-hour overnight gap, and much of it happens while you are asleep.

That is the heart of a gentle practice of intermittent fasting for beginners. You are not skipping meals. You are simply letting the night be a real night for your digestion, with a clear beginning and end.

If your gap is shorter, move one end of it a little at a time. Finish dinner half an hour earlier, or have breakfast half an hour later, and hold that for a week before moving again. Many people find that eating their last meal a few hours before bed also helps them sleep more comfortably. If your sleep is unsettled, my piece on how to fix your sleep schedule may help, because the two petals support each other.

During the gap, water is fine, and so are plain tea and black coffee in the morning, as long as caffeine does not upset your stomach or your sleep. Leave out milk, sugar and anything you would call a drink-and-a-snack.

Keep the twelve-hour gap for at least two or three weeks before you consider anything else. For many people, this is where the practice can stay, comfortably, for good.

Step three, if it suits you: a shorter eating window

Your eating window is simply the part of the day when you eat. With a twelve-hour overnight gap, your window is also about twelve hours. Some people, once that feels easy, like to narrow the window a little more. You may have seen 16 8 fasting mentioned, which means eating within an eight-hour window and not eating for the other sixteen. That is a big step from where most people begin, and it is not something you need to aim for.

If you do want to go further, and your doctor agrees, do it slowly:

StageWhat it looks likeHow long to stay
Closed kitchenNothing after dinnerUntil it feels normal, often a couple of weeks
Twelve-hour gapAbout twelve hours between dinner and breakfastAt least two or three weeks, or for good
A slightly shorter windowMove breakfast or dinner by half an hour or soA week or more at each change

Change one end of the day at a time, and only by a small amount. If a change makes you feel worse, go back to the last stage that felt good and stay there.

My own eating window is from noon to six, two meals most days. That is my practice after many years, and I am not recommending it to anyone. It is a much longer gap than I would suggest anyone begin with, and it is not right for everyone. The timing matters far less than whether you can keep it up calmly. Some people prefer an earlier window, with a good breakfast and lunch and an early, light supper. Choose what fits your life and your health.

What it feels like in the first weeks

Honestly, the first week or two can feel a little odd. You may feel hungry or irritable at the times you used to snack, or wander into the kitchen out of habit. That hunger is usually your body expecting food when you have trained it to expect food, and it tends to rise and settle again.

Hunger is a wave. It rises, and if you let it, it falls again.

Many people find that after a couple of weeks the evening urge fades. Some wake feeling lighter, and some notice no change, which is fine too.

What the gentle version should not feel like is struggle. If you are white-knuckling it every evening, thinking about food all the time, or counting the minutes until breakfast, the practice is not working for you, and that is useful information. Go back a step.

What to eat when you do eat

When you eat matters, but what you eat matters at least as much. A short overnight gap followed by a breakfast of pastries and sweet coffee will leave you hungry again within an hour or two, and the whole thing will feel harder than it needs to.

I eat whole-food, plant-based, and these are the foods that make the gap easy for me:

  • Protein at every meal. Beans, lentils, chickpeas, tofu, tempeh, edamame, soy milk, nuts and seeds.
  • Plenty of fiber. Vegetables, fruit, oats, whole grains, beans and lentils again. Fiber helps meals feel satisfying.
  • Some healthy fat. A little olive oil, avocado, nuts or seeds.
  • Whole foods over packaged ones. The less a food has been processed, the longer it tends to keep me going.

A simple habit from my book that helps here: start your meal with the vegetables and protein, and have the bread or rice after. Many people find this keeps them comfortable for longer.

For ideas, see my high-protein vegan breakfasts.

When your eating window opens, eat normally: not as much as possible, and not less than you need. If you find yourself eating in a rush or feeling out of control around food once the window opens, that is a sign to stop and talk to your doctor.

Is intermittent fasting safe? What to watch for, and when to stop

For many healthy adults, a twelve-hour overnight gap is a fairly ordinary way to eat. But it is not safe for everyone, which is why the list at the top of this page matters. Even if you are not on that list, keep an eye on how you feel.

Stop and speak to your doctor if you notice:

  • dizziness, faintness or shakiness
  • headaches that do not settle
  • feeling unusually cold, weak or tired
  • sleep getting worse instead of better
  • changes to your periods
  • thinking about food much more than before, or worrying about when you can eat
  • eating in a hurried or uncomfortable way when your window opens
  • any new symptom that worries you

Stopping is not failing. The point of this petal is to feel better, and if it does not do that for you, other petals may suit you better for now. Right Movement, Right Rest and Right Breath all ask nothing of your eating at all.

If you would like guided sessions to follow along with, such as gentle morning yoga to start the day, you can find them on Lifetime Body by Design.

A few questions people ask me

What is the best way for beginners to start? Close the kitchen after dinner and aim for a twelve-hour overnight gap. Hold that for a few weeks before you change anything else, and check with your doctor first if you have any health condition or take regular medication.

Is intermittent fasting for women different? It can be. Pregnancy, breastfeeding, the menopause and hormone changes all affect how women respond to changes in eating, and the research in women is still limited. Please speak to your doctor before going beyond a gentle overnight gap.

Will intermittent fasting help me lose weight? I cannot promise that, and nobody honestly can. Some people find that a closed kitchen in the evening means they eat a little less without trying, and others find their weight does not change. I would rather you came to this petal for the steadiness it can bring to your day.


There is more on this petal under Right Fasting. If you are new to building any habit, start with how to build good habits, and for the first, gentlest step, read how to stop snacking between meals.

This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or dietary advice. Please speak to your doctor or a registered dietitian before making significant changes to how or when you eat, especially if you have a health condition or take regular medication.

Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

Letters from Carol

If this was useful, the letters are where the next one arrives first.

No spam, and you can leave whenever you like. See the privacy page.