
You cannot stop every negative thought from arriving, and you do not need to. What you can do is learn how to stop negative thoughts from steering you: notice the thought, question whether it is true or useful, and replace it with one that helps. Done a little every day, that small loop changes the tone of your mind more than any amount of willing yourself to be cheerful.
I am a wellness coach and yoga teacher, and for a long time I was the person in the room with the busiest, harshest inner voice. I tried to fix my body first, with diets and exercise plans, and the plans kept collapsing because my thinking pulled them down. Learning to manage my thoughts was not where I started. Looking back, it is where I should have started, and it is why I put it first for everyone I work with.
Why Right Thinking is the first petal
My method is called the Starflower. It has a stem, which is Right Habits, the work of making good things automatic, and seven petals, each one a "Right Action": Right Thinking, Right Feeding, Right Movement, Right Breath, Right Rest, Right Fasting and Right Connection. You can start the petals in any order, but Right Thinking comes first in the book for a plain reason. Every other petal depends on it.
You can know exactly what to eat, how to move and when to sleep, and still talk yourself out of all of it by Wednesday. The voice that says "you always give up" or "what's the point" is the same voice in every area of life. If you learn to handle it once, every petal gets easier. If you leave it alone, it quietly undoes the rest.
I also think of health as having four bodies: physical, mental, emotional and spiritual. They lean on each other. Thinking sits right in the middle, because it shapes how we feel, what we choose to do with our bodies, and how connected we feel to anything larger than our to-do list.
You are not your thoughts
This is the idea everything else rests on. A thought is something your mind produces, often out of habit. It is not a fact, and it is not you.
Most of the thoughts we have today are close copies of the ones we had yesterday. They run on well-worn tracks: the same worries, the same judgments, the same predictions about how things will go. After enough years, those tracks feel like our personality. We say "I'm just a worrier" or "I've always been hard on myself" as if we were describing our eye color.
But habits of thought behave like any other habit. The more often a pattern runs, the more easily it runs again. The less often it runs, the weaker it gets. That is the hopeful part. A pattern you practiced into being can be practiced out of being, at any age.
I did not really understand this until I started meditating. Sitting still and watching my mind, I saw thoughts arrive, make their case and leave, while something in me stayed exactly the same. That something was doing the watching. It was not the worry.
Once you see a thought as a passing event rather than the truth about you, you get a choice about what to do with it. In my own words from the book: "We always possess the power of choice."
Where negative self talk comes from
Negative self talk is the running commentary that criticizes, predicts the worst and assumes you will fail. It rarely shouts. It usually sounds reasonable, which is why we believe it.
Thoughts and feelings feed each other. A low or anxious feeling tilts the mind toward gloomy thoughts, and gloomy thoughts deepen the feeling. Often the thought is really a feeling looking for a reason. You wake up tired and tense, and within minutes your mind has found three things to be worried about.
A few patterns show up again and again in negative self talk. Once you can name them, they lose a lot of their grip.
- All-or-nothing thinking. One slip means the whole effort has failed. "I missed my walk, so this week is ruined."
- Catastrophizing. A setback becomes a disaster. "If this goes badly, everything falls apart."
- Taking it personally. Someone is short with you and you assume it must be something you did.
- Fortune telling. Deciding how something will turn out before it happens, usually badly.
- Harsh labels. "I'm lazy." "I'm hopeless." A whole person summed up in one cruel word.
Much of my own commentary came from perfectionism. If I could not do something perfectly, some part of me would rather not do it at all, and then it would scold me for not doing it.
How to stop negative self talk: notice, question, replace
This is the core skill of Right Thinking. It takes seconds once you have practiced it, and it works best on ordinary days so that it is ready on hard ones.
1. Notice. Catch the thought and say it back to yourself plainly. "I'm having the thought that I'll never stick with this." Adding "I'm having the thought that" puts a little space between you and the sentence. You are the one noticing it, so you are not the same thing as it.
2. Question. Ask two things. Is this true? And is it useful? Most negative thoughts fail at least one test. Even a thought that is partly true is often useless in the form it arrives in.
3. Replace. Choose a thought that is honest and helpful. Not a slogan, not a lie, just a more accurate sentence that points you toward a next step.
Here is how it looks in practice.
| The thought | A question to ask | A thought that helps |
|---|---|---|
| "I missed yoga, so I've blown it." | Does one missed day undo months? | "I missed one day. I'll go tomorrow." |
| "This will be a disaster." | What is actually happening right now? | "Right now it's just hard. I can take the next step." |
| "They're annoyed with me." | What else could explain it? | "They might be having a bad day. I can ask." |
| "I'm hopeless at this." | Would I say this to a friend? | "I'm new at this. Beginners are meant to be clumsy." |
| "I have to go to work." | Is there another way to see it? | "I get to go to work, and I'll do it well." |
You will not believe every replacement thought the first time. That is fine. You are not trying to win an argument with yourself. You are laying down a new track, and tracks take repetition.
Positive self talk you can actually believe
Positive self talk has a bad reputation because people use it to paper over things. Telling yourself "everything is wonderful" on a terrible day does not help, because a part of you knows it is false and digs in.
The kind that works is closer to how a good coach speaks: honest about the difficulty, then clear about what you can do. "This is hard, and I've done hard things." "I'm nervous, which means this matters to me." "I don't have to finish today. I just have to start."
Small word changes make a surprising difference. "I have to" becomes "I get to." "I'm scared" can become "I'm excited," since the feeling in the body is often much the same. "I always fail" becomes "I haven't managed it yet." None of these are tricks. They are simply truer than the habit they replace.
A thought is a visitor, not a verdict.
Let feelings pass instead of arguing with them
Sometimes the thought is not the problem. The feeling underneath it is, and no amount of clever reframing will move it until the feeling has had its turn.
When that happens, I stop thinking about the feeling and start feeling it. Where is it in the body? Tight chest, hot face, a knot in the stomach? I let it be there without trying to fix it or tell a story about it. I breathe slowly through my nose and keep my attention on the sensation. Feelings that are allowed rather than resisted tend to rise, peak and soften on their own, often within a few minutes.
This is not giving in to the feeling, and it is not acting on it. It is the opposite of both. You let the feeling exist while you decline to follow it anywhere. The breath is the simplest way back into the body, which is why Right Thinking and Right Breath work so closely together.
How to change your mindset: a ten-minute daily practice
Knowing all this changes nothing on its own. What changes your mindset is doing a little of it every day until it becomes the way you think. This is the practice I give people to start with. It takes about ten minutes in total, spread across the day.
In the morning (about four minutes)
- Sit somewhere quiet before you look at your phone.
- Breathe slowly through your nose for two minutes. When a thought pulls you away, notice it, let it go, and come back to the breath.
- Write one or two sentences about the person you are becoming and how you want to meet today. Keep it simple and in the present tense.
During the day (a few seconds, as often as needed)
- When you catch a harsh or gloomy thought, run the loop: notice, question, replace.
- Finish one small thing you have been putting off. Unfinished tasks are a steady drip of negative self talk, and finishing even one quiets it.
In the evening (about four minutes)
- Write down three things you are grateful for from today. Be specific: not "my family" but "the phone call with my friend at lunch."
- Write down one moment when you caught a negative thought and changed it. This trains your attention to notice the skill working.
Keep it this small for the first few weeks. If you miss a day, start again the next morning without a lecture to yourself. The habit is built by returning, not by never slipping. My piece on building good habits has more on making a practice stick, and if you would like to be guided through it, there are live sessions at Lifetime Body by Design.
When negative thoughts need more than a practice
Everything above is for the ordinary negative thinking that most of us live with. It is not a treatment for illness, and it is not a substitute for care.
If your low mood lasts for more than a couple of weeks, if anxiety is getting in the way of daily life, or if you have thoughts of harming yourself, please speak to your doctor. If you are in danger right now, call your local emergency number. In the US and Canada you can call or text 988 to reach a crisis line at any hour. Asking for help is a Right Action too, and a strong one.
A good doctor or therapist can work alongside a daily practice like this one. You do not have to choose between them.
A few questions people ask me
Can you really stop negative thoughts completely? No, and that is not the goal. Thoughts will keep arriving. The aim is to stop believing and obeying every one of them, so they pass through instead of taking over.
How long does it take to change negative self talk? Many people find they notice a difference within a few weeks of daily practice, mainly in how quickly they catch a thought. The deeper change takes longer, the way any habit does. I wrote about that in how long it takes to form a habit.
What if the replacement thought feels fake? Make it smaller and more honest. "I'm going to be great at this" may feel false, but "I'm going to try for ten minutes" is simply true. Believable beats bright.
Is overthinking the same as negative thinking? They overlap. Overthinking is the habit of going round and round, and it is often negative, but not always. I wrote a separate piece on how to stop overthinking.
There is more on this petal under Right Thinking. If you are starting from the beginning, read how to build good habits, the stem that holds every petal up.
This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or psychological advice. If you are struggling with your mood, with anxiety or with thoughts of harming yourself, please speak to your doctor or a qualified mental health professional.
Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.
