Fundamental movement
Yoga vs pilates: how they differ, from a yoga teacher
By Carol Pocock8 minute read

The short answer to yoga vs pilates: yoga is an old practice that links breath, held poses and stillness to work the whole body and settle the mind, while pilates is a younger method of controlled, precise exercises that builds strength outward from the core. They overlap more than people expect. Both build strength, both ask for close attention, and both can be gentle on the joints. The real difference is in what each one puts at the center.
I am a wellness coach and a yoga teacher, and I did my yoga teacher training in India. My daily base is an hour of yoga, mostly power yoga and hot yoga, with running and walking around it. So I should say plainly where I stand: I teach yoga, not pilates, and I am not a pilates instructor. What follows is how the two compare from the outside of one and the inside of the other, and I have tried to be fair to both. I have a great deal of respect for what a good pilates class does.
Where this sits in the Starflower
In the method at the heart of my book, Lifetime Body by Design, movement is Right Movement, the third petal of the Starflower. A "petal" is one of seven daily Right Actions, each a fundamental of health made into a habit. The centerpiece of this petal is what I call the Foundational Hour: one dedicated hour, most days, of movement that works the whole body from head to toe.
Yoga is my Foundational Hour. Pilates could be someone else's. That is really the question this piece is trying to help you answer: not which one is better in the abstract, but which one you would keep doing. If you are new to all of this, the pillar on how to start exercising explains how to build up from ten minutes a day.
Where each one comes from
Yoga is thousands of years old and comes from India. Postures are only one part of it. The wider practice includes breathing, concentration and meditation, and many styles still carry that thread even in a busy studio. Modern yoga comes in many styles, from slow and restful to strong and sweaty, which I set out in types of yoga.
Pilates is far younger. According to the Pilates Method Alliance, the method was created by Joseph Pilates, who was born in Germany in 1883, brought his system of corrective exercise to America in the late 1920s and called it Contrology. The name says a lot. The whole method is about controlling movement precisely, from the center of the body outward.
The difference between yoga and pilates
Here is the comparison as I would put it to a friend. These are general tendencies, and individual classes vary a great deal.
| Yoga | Pilates | |
|---|---|---|
| What sits at the center | Breath, the whole body and the mind together | Core control and precise movement |
| How a session moves | Poses held for several breaths, or flowed one into the next | Sets of controlled exercises, often with careful repetitions |
| Equipment | A mat, sometimes a block or strap | A mat, or spring-loaded machines such as the reformer |
| The breath | Used to link movement and to steady attention | Coordinated with each exercise to support control |
| Stillness and meditation | Often part of the class | Not usually part of the method |
| Flexibility | A strong emphasis in most styles | Part of the work, alongside control |
| Pace and heat | From gentle to vigorous, and some rooms are heated | Usually steady and focused |
The simplest way I can say it: yoga tends to ask you to hold a shape and breathe into it, then move on. Pilates tends to ask you to move a small part of the body with great precision while the rest stays steady. Both are hard work done well.
What they have in common
People sometimes set yoga and pilates up as rivals, and I do not think they are. They share more than divides them.
- Both build real strength. You lift, lower and hold your own body, and in pilates sometimes the resistance of springs. Neither is "just stretching".
- Both care about alignment. In my own teaching I start from the feet, as I describe in mountain pose. Pilates teachers start from the center. Both are after a body that is stacked well and moves well.
- Both ask for attention. You cannot do either one well while thinking about your shopping list.
- Both are low impact. Neither involves jumping or pounding, which is part of why so many people find them kind to their joints.
- Both work the core. Pilates is famous for it. Yoga does it too, mostly through holding steady, which I explain in how to build core strength.
Is yoga or pilates better?
Honestly, neither. The better one is the one you will turn up for, week after week. That is the whole point of a habit, and it is why I start every part of my method with the stem, Right Habits, as I explain in how to build good habits.
That said, the two do suit different people and different days.
Yoga may suit you if you want movement and stillness in the same hour, you like the idea of the breath leading the way, you want flexibility and balance alongside strength, or you would like a practice you can do anywhere with nothing more than a little floor space.
Pilates may suit you if you like clear, precise instructions, you want to feel exactly which muscles are working, you enjoy a steady and focused pace, or you are drawn to the machines, which many people find give useful support and feedback.
The best practice is not the one with the most benefits. It is the one you keep.
Yoga or pilates for beginners
Both welcome beginners. What matters most is choosing a class labelled for beginners and telling the teacher you are new.
In yoga, look for a gentle, basics or beginners class before you try a strong or heated one. My piece on yoga for beginners walks through what a first class is really like. In pilates, a beginners mat class is a common first step, and studios with machines usually ask new students to start with an introductory session so the teacher can show them how the equipment works.
Whichever you choose, go more than once before you decide. The first class of anything feels awkward. The third one tells you much more.
Some people do both, and that is a fine choice. Many find that the precise core work of pilates and the breath and flexibility of yoga complement each other. If you would like guided yoga sessions to follow along with at home, you will find them at Lifetime Body by Design.
The breath in each
Breath is where I notice the biggest difference in feel. In the yoga I teach, the breath is slow and steady through the nose, and it sets the pace of the whole practice. In pilates, the breath is closely timed to each exercise to help you stay in control. Neither is wrong. If the role of the breath interests you, I wrote about it more in how to breathe properly.
When to ask your doctor first
Please speak to your doctor or a physical therapist before starting either practice if you have back or neck problems, joint pain, osteoporosis, a recent injury or surgery, high blood pressure or a heart condition, or if you are pregnant. Tell the teacher too, before the class starts, so they can offer adjustments. Effort is normal. Sharp pain, numbness or dizziness means stop.
A few questions people ask me
Is pilates the same as yoga? No. They share some shapes and a focus on control, but pilates is a separate, much younger method built around core control, while yoga brings breath, poses and stillness together.
Which is better for flexibility? Most yoga styles place more emphasis on flexibility, though pilates works on it too. Either will help if you practice regularly.
Can I do yoga and pilates in the same week? Yes. Many people do, and they can sit well side by side. Give your body easy days in between, especially at first.
Is one better for weight loss? I would not choose either on that basis. Move for how it makes you feel today, and choose the one you enjoy enough to keep.
There is more on this petal under Fundamental movement, starting with how to start exercising. If you lean toward yoga, yoga for beginners is the place to begin.
This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical advice. Please speak to your doctor or a physical therapist before starting a new exercise practice, especially if you have back, neck or joint problems, an injury, osteoporosis, a heart condition, are pregnant or take regular medication.
Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

