Skip to the page

Thinking

Fixed mindset vs growth mindset, in plain words

By Carol Pocock8 minute read

Ink and watercolor sketch of a cloth-bound book resting on a stack of manuscript pages tied with string.

The difference between a fixed mindset vs growth mindset comes down to one belief. A fixed mindset assumes your abilities and qualities are set: you are good at something or you are not. A growth mindset assumes they can be built with practice, time and better methods, so a struggle is a stage rather than a verdict.

I am a wellness coach and yoga teacher, and I spent years living on the fixed side without knowing it had a name. I struggled with my weight and with yo-yo dieting for a long time, and each failed attempt filed itself away as proof of what kind of person I was. Learning that this was a way of thinking, and not a fact about me, mattered more than any new plan. If you want a practical method for shifting a belief, I wrote one up in how to change your mindset. This piece is the step before that: what the two terms actually mean, and how to hear them in your own head.

What a fixed mindset means

A fixed mindset treats ability as something handed out at birth. You have a certain amount of talent, intelligence, willpower or fitness, and life is mostly a matter of finding out how much.

The trouble is what follows from that. If ability is fixed, every attempt becomes a test of who you are. Doing badly is not information, it is exposure. So the sensible thing, from inside that belief, is to avoid situations where you might look bad: skip the class, quit before the plateau, stick to what you already do well. A fixed mindset is not lazy. It is protective: it keeps you from feeling like a failure by keeping you small.

You can usually hear it in short, final sentences. "I'm just not sporty." "I've never been able to cook." "That's how I am."

What a growth mindset means

A growth mindset treats ability as something you develop. Where you start is only where you start. Effort, practice, good advice and changing your approach all move you forward, and so does getting it wrong.

From inside this belief, a struggle means you are at the edge of what you can currently do, which is exactly where learning happens. A setback says "not yet" rather than "never." As I put it in my book, Lifetime Body by Design, "if we want to excel at something, we must first be willing to be awful at it."

A growth mindset is not the same as positive thinking, and it does not mean pretending effort alone fixes everything. Working harder at a method that is not working is just more of the same. The growth view includes trying a different way, asking for help and resting when you need to.

How they sound in everyday life

The clearest way I know to tell them apart is to listen to the same moment through both. Here are some ordinary ones.

MomentFixed mindset saysGrowth mindset says
You ate more than you meant to at dinner"I have no self-control around food.""I was very hungry by then. Lunch was too small, so that is the thing to change."
You tried a new vegetable and disliked it"I just don't like vegetables.""Not that way. I'll try it roasted, or try another one."
A yoga class was harder than you expected"My body doesn't do this.""My hips are tight right now. That is what practice is for."
You gave up on a walk halfway"I'm not a walker. I never stick with things.""Twenty minutes was too far for this week. Ten, then."
You slept badly three nights running"I'm a terrible sleeper. Always have been.""Something about my evenings has changed. What is it?"
You missed a few days of a new routine"Here I go again. I always quit.""I missed a few days. I can start again tomorrow."
A friendship has drifted"I'm bad at keeping friends.""I've been quiet. I could send a message this week."
Someone gives you feedback you did not want"So they think I'm useless.""That stings, and part of it might be useful."

Notice that the growth answers are not cheerful. They are just more accurate. They describe what happened and leave a door open, where the fixed answers turn one event into a life sentence.

Nobody is purely one or the other

I want to be honest about this part, because it is often left out. Nobody has a growth mindset about everything. Most of us carry both, and which one shows up depends on the subject, the day and how tired we are.

You might have a wonderfully open attitude to work and a completely fixed one about your body. You might believe anyone can learn to cook, except you. You might be patient with a friend learning to swim and merciless with yourself over a missed run. I still catch the fixed voice in myself, usually when I am short on sleep or trying something new in front of other people.

So the aim is not to become a "growth mindset person," which would just be another fixed label. The aim is to notice which voice is talking in a particular area of your life, and to give the other one a turn. In Right Thinking, the first petal of my method, the starting point is that we are not our thoughts. A mindset is a habit of thought, and you are the one who can watch it.

Why it matters for your health

Health is built out of small repeated actions: what you eat, how you move, when you sleep, who you see. Every one of those involves bad days, slow progress and plateaus. A fixed mindset reads each of those as evidence against you, so it tends to quit at exactly the point where habits are about to settle.

This is why mindset sits underneath everything else in my method, the Starflower. It has a stem, Right Habits, and seven petals, each a "Right Action": Right Thinking, Right Feeding, Right Movement, Right Breath, Right Rest, Right Fasting and Right Connection. Right Thinking comes first because the way you interpret a bad week decides whether you are still there the week after. My rule of never skipping twice only works if a missed day is allowed to be a missed day, rather than a judgment of your character. There is more on that in how to build good habits.

How to move toward a growth mindset

I will keep this short, since the full method is in how to change your mindset. A few things help.

  • Listen for final words. "Always", "never", "just not" and "that's how I am" are the fixed mindset's favorite phrases. Hearing them is the first step.
  • Add "yet." "I can't run for ten minutes" becomes "I can't run for ten minutes yet." It sounds too simple to matter, and it changes the shape of the sentence.
  • Describe, don't diagnose. Say what happened ("I skipped two walks") rather than what it means about you ("I'm hopeless").
  • Change the method before you blame yourself. If something keeps failing, make it smaller, move it to another time of day or ask someone who does it well.

If you find the critical voice in your head is loud more often than not, my pillar piece on how to stop negative thoughts goes into handling those thoughts one at a time. And if a fixed belief about your body has kept you from moving, how to start exercising is a gentle place to begin. For live guided sessions with other people, there is Lifetime Body by Design.

A setback says "not yet". Only the fixed mindset hears "never".

A few questions people ask me

Is a growth mindset just positive thinking? No. Positive thinking tells you things are fine. A growth mindset accepts that something went badly and asks what would help next time. It is more honest, not more cheerful.

Can you have a growth mindset about some things and a fixed one about others? Yes, and almost everyone does. It is more useful to ask "which mindset do I have about this?" than "which mindset do I have?"

Is a fixed mindset always bad? It is understandable, and some limits are real: an injury, a health condition or simply the hours in your day. A growth mindset does not ignore those. It just stops treating every difficulty as one of them.

What if my low mood makes everything feel fixed? Then please be gentle with yourself and speak to your doctor. Persistent low mood is not a mindset problem to be argued with, and it deserves proper support.


There is more on this petal under Right Thinking, beginning with how to stop negative thoughts.

This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or psychological advice. If you are struggling with your mood, with anxiety or with thoughts of harming yourself, please speak to your doctor or a qualified mental health professional.

Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

Letters from Carol

If this was useful, the letters are where the next one arrives first.

No spam, and you can leave whenever you like. See the privacy page.