Skip to the page

Thinking

How to be yourself when you are not sure who that is

By Carol Pocock8 minute read

Ink and watercolor sketch of an open wooden gate and a garden path leading into a sunlit garden.

Learning how to be yourself is less about discovering a hidden person and more about noticing the habits that cover the one already there. You find yourself by paying attention to what you value, catching the moments when you perform for other people, and making small choices that match what you actually think. Done often enough, those choices stop feeling brave and start feeling like home.

I am a wellness coach and yoga teacher, and much of my work is helping people change habits of body and mind. The idea at the center of how I teach thinking is that we are not our thoughts, and it turns out to be the most useful idea I know for this question too. If you are not sure who you are, you are in good company. Most people have never been asked to look.

Why "just be yourself" is hard advice to follow

People say "just be yourself" as if it were simple. It assumes you know who that is, and that it is safe to show. For a lot of us, neither is quite true.

Many people spent years becoming whoever kept the peace: the easy child, the reliable colleague, the friend who never needs anything. Those roles were useful once. The trouble is that a role practiced for long enough feels like a personality. When someone finally asks "but what do you want?", there is a blank where the answer should be.

That blank is not a sign that something is missing. It is a sign that a habit has been running for a long time. Habits can be noticed and changed, which is good news, because it means being yourself is something you can practice rather than something you either have or lack.

You are not your habits, and you are not your roles

In my approach, this belongs to Right Thinking, the first petal of the Starflower, the seven daily fundamentals I build health on. Right Thinking starts from a plain observation: thoughts and feelings come and go, but the one noticing them stays. In my book, Lifetime Body by Design, I put it simply: "Our real self always stays the same."

That changes the question. Instead of hunting for a self you have never met, you start removing what is not you: the automatic yes, the opinion borrowed to fit in, the version of you that shows up only to avoid a frown. What remains when those quiet down is not a stranger. It is usually someone you recognize.

I wrote more about the idea behind this in how to stop negative thoughts, the main essay on this petal.

How to know yourself: start with what you notice

You do not need a personality test to know yourself. You need a few weeks of honest noticing. These are the questions I suggest people carry around with them:

  • When do I lose track of time? The things that absorb you say more about you than the things that impress others.
  • What do I defend, even when it costs me? Those are your values, whether or not you have named them.
  • Whose approval am I reaching for right now? Ask it in the moment, not afterwards.
  • What would I do this weekend if nobody would ever know?
  • What drains me, even when I am good at it?

Write the answers down as they come, a line at a time. Patterns appear quickly. If you would like more prompts, I have collected them in self-reflection questions.

How to stop pretending, one small moment at a time

Pretending is rarely one big lie. It is a hundred small adjustments: laughing at a joke you did not find funny, agreeing with an opinion you do not hold, saying "I don't mind" when you do. Each one is tiny. Together they become a way of living.

You do not stop by announcing a new you. You stop the way you change any habit, with one small, repeatable act. Pick a single place where you usually adjust yourself and do the honest version instead, gently:

Where you usually performA small honest version
"Wherever you like" when asked to chooseName one place you would actually enjoy
Nodding along to an opinion you disagree with"I see it a bit differently, actually."
Saying yes to a favor you have no time for"I can't this week, but I could next week."
Hiding something you love because it seems oddMention it once, without apology

The first few times feel awkward. That awkwardness is the old habit noticing it is being replaced. Most people find the reaction from others is far milder than they feared, and often warmer. If the automatic yes is your strongest habit, my piece on how to stop people pleasing goes into it in more depth.

How to be yourself around others

This is where most of us struggle, because being yourself alone is easy. A few things help.

Lower the stakes. You do not have to be fully yourself with everyone at once. Start with the people who feel safest, and let the habit grow outward from there.

Let some people not like you. If everyone likes you, there is a good chance some of them like a version you are performing. Being yourself means a few people will drift away, and the ones who stay will be staying for the real you.

Notice your body. When I am performing, I can feel it: the shoulders lift, the breath gets high and short, the smile stays on a moment too long. When I am at ease, the breath drops low again. The body often knows before the mind does, and a slow breath through the nose is a quiet way to come back to yourself in the middle of a conversation. If you want to understand that better, read how to breathe properly.

Keep your word to yourself. Being authentic is not only about what you show others. It is also about whether you do what you told yourself you would. Each small promise kept builds the quiet confidence that makes being yourself in public easier.

Being yourself is not a discovery you make once. It is a habit you keep.

Being authentic as a daily habit

Like everything in my work, this rests on the stem of the Starflower, Right Habits: small actions done daily until they run on their own. A few anchors that help:

  1. A quiet start. A few minutes of sitting with the breath before the day begins. It is the practice that taught me my thoughts are not me, and it makes it easier to hear what I actually think. If you would like guidance, there are live sessions at Lifetime Body by Design.
  2. One honest choice a day. Pick it in the morning if that helps: the restaurant, the opinion, the "no".
  3. A line in a notebook at night. Where did I feel like myself today, and where did I not?

None of this needs to be dramatic. It needs to be daily. My essay on how to build good habits explains why small and steady works better than a sudden reinvention.

When it is more than not knowing yourself

Feeling unsure of who you are is a normal part of life, especially after a big change such as a move, a loss, retirement or the end of a relationship. But if you feel empty or disconnected from yourself most days for weeks, if your mood stays low, or if you have any thoughts of harming yourself, please speak to your doctor. Those are health matters, and good help is available. A practice like this one sits alongside proper care.

A few questions people ask me

What does it mean to be yourself? To me, it means your choices and words match what you actually value and think, most of the time, without needing everyone's approval first.

Can you be yourself and still fit in? You can, and most of us do. Fitting in by adjusting a little for good manners is kind. Fitting in by hiding what you think is the habit worth changing.

What if I don't like who I am? Then start with how you treat yourself, not with who you are. Small kindnesses kept daily change how you feel about the person receiving them. My piece on how to love yourself is about exactly that.

How long does it take to feel like myself? It varies. Many people notice a difference within a few weeks of small daily choices, and it keeps growing from there.


There is more on the first petal under Right Thinking. If other people's opinions are what hold you back, read how to stop caring what others think next.

This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or psychological advice. If you are struggling with low mood, anxiety or thoughts of harming yourself, please speak to your doctor or a qualified mental health professional.

Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

Letters from Carol

If this was useful, the letters are where the next one arrives first.

No spam, and you can leave whenever you like. See the privacy page.