Skip to the page

Habits

How to stay consistent when the novelty wears off

By Carol Pocock8 minute read

Ink and watercolor sketch of an open wooden gate and a garden path.

If you want to know how to stay consistent, stop judging the habit by how it feels after the first few weeks and start judging it by whether you kept the thread. Consistency is not doing the full version every day. It is having a smallest version ready for the dip, the boring stretch, the trip away and the bad week, and coming back the very next day whenever you miss.

I am a wellness coach and yoga teacher, and for years I was very good at the first three weeks of everything. New plan, new class, new food rules: the enthusiasm was always there at the start, and it always faded. I struggled with my weight and with yo-yo dieting for a long time before I understood that the problem was never the start. It was what I did once the novelty wore off.

What consistency really is, and what it is not

In my method, Lifetime Body by Design, health is built from a few fundamentals drawn as the Starflower: seven petals, each a "Right Action", held up by a stem called Right Habits. This piece belongs to the stem. If you have not built a habit on purpose before, start with how to build good habits that last, which covers the starting. This piece is about the weeks after.

My piece on self-discipline is about arranging your days so the right thing is the easy thing. Consistency is what happens over months when that setup meets real life: holidays, colds, a week when you simply do not care.

  • Consistency is not perfection. A year with forty missed days and no long gaps is a very consistent year.
  • It is not intensity. As I put it in my book, "A small routine kept beats a big one abandoned."
  • It is the thread. As long as the habit shows up in some form most days, and never vanishes for long, you are being consistent.

The dip: the weeks after the novelty goes

Every habit has a honeymoon, and then a dip. Somewhere around the second or third week, the excitement is gone and the benefits have not arrived yet. Every morning becomes a negotiation.

It helps a great deal to know this is normal. The benefits of most healthy habits build quietly before they show. You can do everything right and see nothing for weeks, then notice one day that the stairs are easier. I wrote more about the timing in how long does it take to form a habit?

What gets you through the dip:

  • Measure showing up, not results. A mark on a calendar for every day you did it, even the smallest version.
  • Shrink, do not stop. If the full habit feels impossible, do a tenth of it. Ten minutes of walking still counts as the walk.
  • Remember why you started. Write your reason down in specific words and keep it where you will see it.

When it gets boring

Boredom is a different problem from the dip, and it comes later. The habit works, you know it works, and it has become dull. This is actually a sign of success: boring means automatic. But it is also when people drift.

The trick is to change the inside of the habit and keep the outside fixed. Keep the time, the place and the cue exactly the same, because those are what make it automatic. Change what happens within them.

  • Walk a different route, but leave at the same time.
  • Try a new class or style, but on the same mornings.
  • Cook a new bean dish, but on the same batch-cooking day.

If the habit has grown too big or too small for your life, adjust the size. Do not abandon the slot.

How to stay motivated when nothing seems to change

Motivation is lovely at the start, and it does not last. It is not supposed to. What keeps you going later is the habit itself, plus a reason you actually care about.

A vague reason ("to be healthier") runs out fast. A specific one, such as keeping up on a long walk with friends or getting down onto the floor and back up easily, carries you much further.

The other thing that helps is noticing the reward you get today, not the one promised for next year. For me, the calm after my yoga and the lift after a run are what I look forward to. I love yoga, so rolling out the mat costs me nothing. Running is different: I almost always have to talk myself out of the door, and I go anyway, because I know how I will feel at the end. If exercise is your sticking point, I wrote a separate piece on how to get motivated to exercise.

Travel, illness and the bad week

Most habits do not die in the dip. They die on a trip, during a cold, or in one awful week, and then never come back. The way through is to decide in advance what consistency looks like in each of those situations, so you are not working it out when you are tired.

What happensWhat consistency looks like
A trip awayThe same wake time if you can, a walk to explore instead of your usual session, one decent meal a day
A cold or a minor illnessRest is the habit this week. Keep the wake time, drink water, and let the movement go
A bad week at work or at homeThe smallest version of one habit only, your Anchor Habit, and nothing else
Visitors or a holidayA shorter version at the usual time, before the house wakes up
Pure lack of interestThe smallest version, done anyway, and a check on whether the habit needs changing

Being ill is the one time I would not do even the small version of a demanding habit. Rest is a Right Action too. If you are unwell for more than a few days, or you are not sure whether it is safe to exercise, ask your doctor before you start again.

Never skip twice, in practice

My rule for every habit is never skip twice. One missed day does very little harm; a University College London study of habit formation found that a single missed day made little difference to how the habit formed. Two days in a row is where a routine starts to slip away, because the second day off makes the third feel normal.

What that looks like in real life:

  1. You miss a day. Fine. Do not make it up with a double session tomorrow. That only makes tomorrow harder.
  2. The next day becomes the most important day of the habit. Do it first, before anything else can get in the way, even if it is the smallest version.
  3. The smallest version counts. Five minutes on the mat, one walk to the corner, one cooked meal. The point is that the habit happened.
  4. No commentary. A missed day is just a missed day. It is not a verdict on you.

And if you do skip twice, or ten times, the rule does not turn into a failure. It simply starts again from today.

Starting again after a long gap

Sometimes the thread breaks completely. Coming back, people try to restart at the level they left, feel terrible, and quit again.

Start smaller than you were. Go back to one habit, your Anchor Habit, the one daily habit you enjoy that steadies the rest. Do its smallest version for a week or two before you add anything. The skill of coming back is part of consistency, and it gets easier every time you use it.

If you would like company for the restart, there are guided sessions to follow along with at Lifetime Body by Design.

Keep the thread. A thin thread is still a thread.

A few questions people ask me

How do I be consistent when I have no motivation? Do not wait for it. Make the habit small enough that motivation does not matter, put the cue where you will see it, and start. Feeling like it often follows doing it.

What if I keep falling off after a few weeks? That is usually the dip, and the habit was probably too big to survive it. Halve it, keep the time fixed, and count showing up.

Should I take rest days? Yes, when your body needs them, and always when you are ill. Rest days planned in advance are part of the routine, not a break from it.


There is more on the stem under Right Habits, starting with how to build good habits that last and self-discipline. For the rest petal, see how to rest.

This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical advice. Please speak to your doctor before starting or returning to exercise after an illness, or if you have a health condition or ongoing low mood.

Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

Letters from Carol

If this was useful, the letters are where the next one arrives first.

No spam, and you can leave whenever you like. See the privacy page.