Skip to the page

Fasting

What breaks a fast? A plain answer for the overnight gap

By Carol Pocock8 minute read

Ink and watercolor sketch of a steaming mug on a windowsill at sunrise, with a rolled yoga mat, a folded blanket and a small plant.

For the gentle overnight fast I teach, the answer to what breaks a fast is simple: anything with calories. Plain water, plain tea and black coffee are fine for most people, while milk, sugar, juice, smoothies and food of any kind end the fast. Medicines are a separate matter: always take them exactly as prescribed, whatever that means for your fast.

I am a wellness coach and a yoga teacher, and I have eaten whole-food, plant-based for about thirty years. People ask me this more than almost anything else about fasting, usually holding a cup of coffee. This answer is for the kind of fast this site talks about: a twelve-hour gap overnight, and perhaps a slightly shorter eating window later. It is not written for long fasts, and it is not an argument that everyone should fast.

First: who should not fast without medical advice

Please read this before anything else. Some people should not try any form of fasting, even a gentle overnight gap, without their doctor's advice. That includes anyone who is:

  • pregnant or breastfeeding
  • under eighteen
  • underweight
  • living with, or recovering from, disordered eating of any kind
  • living with diabetes, or taking medicine that affects blood sugar
  • taking medicine that affects blood pressure
  • taking any medicine that needs to be taken with food or at set times

If you have any health condition or take regular medication, speak to your doctor before you change when you eat. Fasting is optional. Plenty of people eat well and feel well without ever thinking about it, and if a fasting window does not suit you, you lose nothing by leaving it alone.

What "breaking a fast" means here

Right Fasting is the sixth petal of the Starflower, the method in my book, Lifetime Body by Design. Each petal is a Right Action, one everyday practice among seven, and in its gentle form this one means giving your body a regular stretch each night when it is not digesting anything. You finish dinner, close the kitchen and eat again at breakfast. If you have not started yet, my guide on how to start intermittent fasting gently walks through the steps.

Breaking the fast simply means ending that stretch. You will find long arguments online about exactly how many calories "count", but for a twelve-hour gap the plainest rule is the best one: if it is food, or a drink with calories in it, the fast is over and your eating day has begun. That is not a failure. It is breakfast.

A quick guide to what breaks a fast

What you haveDoes it end the overnight gap?A note
Plain water, still or sparklingNoDrink when you are thirsty
Black coffeeNo, for most peopleMind your stomach and your sleep
Plain tea: black, green or herbalNoCheck herbal blends for added fruit or sweetener
A slice of lemon in hot waterIn practice, noA trace of juice, not a meal
Milk or plant milk in coffee or teaStrictly, yesSee below
Sugar, honey or syrupYes
Sweeteners and diet drinksNot by caloriesI leave them out; see below
Juice, smoothies and shakesYesFood in a glass
Broth or soupYes
AlcoholYesAnd it tends to unsettle sleep
Toothpaste and mouthwashNoRinse and spit
Prescribed medicineTake it as prescribedAsk about timing with food
Gummy or chewable vitaminsUsually, yesMany contain sugar

Water, black coffee and plain tea

Water is the easy one: drink it whenever you are thirsty. Black coffee and plain tea are fine for most people. Two cautions. Coffee on an empty stomach upsets some people, and if it upsets you, have it with breakfast instead. And caffeine late in the day can cost you sleep, which matters more than any fasting window. I call caffeine my love and my nemesis, so I say this with some feeling. If you are pregnant, have a heart condition or have been told to limit caffeine, follow your doctor's advice on how much.

If your sleep is not what it should be, my piece on how to fix your sleep schedule may help. Right Rest and Right Fasting lean on each other.

Milk in coffee: the question everyone asks

Strictly speaking, yes, milk breaks a fast, whether it is dairy or plant milk, because it has calories. A splash is a small amount, but it is still food.

In practice, I would rather you kept a steady gap with a splash of milk in your first coffee than gave up because black coffee felt unbearable. There are two honest ways to handle it. You can count that first milky coffee as the start of your eating day and plan around it. Or you can move the milky coffee to breakfast and drink water or plain tea until then. Either is fine. What matters is a gap you can keep calmly, not a perfect one.

Sweeteners, diet drinks and chewing gum

Sweeteners and diet drinks have little or no energy in them, so by the calorie rule they do not end the fast. Even so, I leave them out. Many people find that something sweet keeps them thinking about food, and the gap works best when it is plain and quiet.

A piece of sugar-free gum is a very small thing, and not worth worrying over. If you find yourself working through a packet, notice what is going on.

Medicines and supplements

This one matters most, so I will be plain about it.

  • Always take your medicine exactly as prescribed, at the times prescribed. A fasting window never comes before a medicine.
  • If a medicine is meant to be taken with food, take it with food, even if that means eating earlier than you planned.
  • Never skip, delay or reduce a dose to keep a fast.
  • Ask your doctor or pharmacist about how any medicine you take fits with the times you eat. They can tell you which need food, which are best on an empty stomach and which do not mind.

Supplements are a smaller question. Some are designed to be taken with a meal, and some upset an empty stomach. Gummy and chewable vitamins often contain sugar, which ends the gap. Your pharmacist can tell you how to time whatever you take.

If you break your fast by accident

You will, sometimes: a cookie at a friend's house, a milky tea someone hands you. Nothing has gone wrong. The overnight gap is a rhythm, not a test.

The rule I hold myself to with any habit is never to skip twice. One evening off is just one evening. Tomorrow, close the kitchen after dinner as usual. There is more on that in my piece on how to build good habits.

A gap you can keep calmly is worth more than a perfect one you dread.

When the gap does end, end it with a real meal: some protein, some fiber, some vegetables, eaten sitting down. A pastry and a sweet coffee will leave most people hungry again within the hour. If you would like guided sessions to start the morning with, you can find them on Lifetime Body by Design.

A few questions people ask me

Does lemon water break a fast? A slice of lemon in water or hot water is a trace of juice, and I treat it as fine. A glass of lemonade, or lemon with honey, is a different thing and does end the gap.

Does a splash of milk in coffee break a fast? Strictly, yes. In practice, if that splash is what makes the morning possible, count it as the start of your eating day, or save the milky coffee for breakfast.

Can I take my medicine while fasting? Always take it as prescribed. If it needs food, eat. Ask your doctor or pharmacist about timing, and never change a dose to fit a fast.

Should everyone fast? No. It is one option among many, it is not right for everyone, and the people on the list at the top of this page should talk to their doctor before trying any form of it.


There is more on this petal under Right Fasting. To begin, read how to start intermittent fasting gently, and if your mornings start with poor sleep, try how to fix your sleep schedule.

This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or dietary advice. Please speak to your doctor, pharmacist or a registered dietitian before making significant changes to how or when you eat, especially if you have a health condition or take regular medication.

Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

Letters from Carol

If this was useful, the letters are where the next one arrives first.

No spam, and you can leave whenever you like. See the privacy page.