Skip to the page

Whole food nutrition

Homemade peanut butter: one ingredient and a little patience

By Carol Pocock7 minute read

Ink and watercolor sketch of a steaming mug on a windowsill at sunrise beside a rolled yoga mat, a folded blanket and a plant.

Homemade peanut butter takes one ingredient: roasted peanuts. Put about two cups of them in a food processor and let it run for roughly eight to twelve minutes, scraping down the sides now and then, until the crumbs turn into a smooth, pourable butter. A pinch of salt is optional. You do not need to add oil or sugar, only a little patience while the machine does its work.

I am a wellness coach, and I have eaten whole-food, plant-based for about thirty years, with no meat or dairy. Food is Right Feeding, the second petal of the Starflower, the method in my book, Lifetime Body by Design. Much of that petal comes down to choosing foods you can recognize and, where it is easy, making them yourself. If you are new to this way of eating, start with how to go plant-based. Peanut butter is about as easy as it gets.

What natural peanut butter really is

Turn a few jars around in the shop and read the labels. Many list peanuts, then sugar, salt and a hardened or added oil to stop the jar separating. The plainer ones list peanuts and salt, or peanuts alone. That short label is what people usually mean by natural peanut butter, and it is exactly what you make at home.

Peanuts are not true nuts. The University of Georgia's College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences describes them as the seeds of a plant related to peas and beans, which is why I count them with the legumes in my piece on what legumes are. In the kitchen, though, they behave like any nut butter: grind them long enough and their own oil turns them creamy.

What you need

  • 2 cups (about 300 g) roasted, unsalted peanuts. Dry-roasted with nothing added is ideal. Skins on or off both work; skins give a slightly darker, more rustic butter.
  • A pinch of salt, about ¼ teaspoon, if you like. Leave it out if your peanuts are already salted.
  • A food processor. A standard size is easiest. A high-speed blender can work, but it needs a larger amount to catch the blades and tends to overheat.
  • A spatula and a clean jar.

That is all. Two cups makes roughly one cup of peanut butter, since the nuts lose their air as they grind.

How to make peanut butter, step by step

  1. Roast, if your peanuts are raw. Spread them on a tray and roast at 350°F (175°C) for about 10 to 15 minutes, shaking the tray halfway, until golden and fragrant. Let them cool until just warm. Warm peanuts tend to turn creamy sooner.
  2. Process. Tip the peanuts into the food processor and run it. The first minute gives you coarse crumbs, then fine meal.
  3. Scrape and keep going. Around minutes two to four, the meal clumps into a thick paste and sometimes a stiff ball that thumps around the bowl. This is where most people give up and reach for oil. Do not. Stop, scrape the sides and the bottom, and run it again.
  4. Wait for it to loosen. Somewhere between minutes five and twelve, the paste turns glossy and starts to flow. Keep scraping every couple of minutes.
  5. Season and jar. Add the pinch of salt, run for a few more seconds, taste, then spoon it into the jar.

Times vary a lot with your machine and your peanuts. If the motor or the bowl gets hot, switch it off for a few minutes and let it rest. That pause is good for the machine and does no harm to the butter.

If it looks stuck, it is not finished. Scrape it down and keep going.

Crunchy, smooth and a few variations

For crunchy peanut butter, take out about half a cup (about 70 g) of the peanuts before you start, pulse them separately into rough pieces, and stir them into the finished smooth butter.

VersionWhat to addWhen
SmoothNothing, or a pinch of saltAt the end
CrunchyHalf a cup of roughly chopped peanutsStirred in after processing
Cinnamon½ teaspoon ground cinnamonLast 30 seconds
Cocoa1 to 2 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powderLast 30 seconds
Mixed nut butterSwap up to half the peanuts for almonds or cashewsFrom the start, roasted

The same method makes almond, cashew or sunflower seed butter. Harder nuts like almonds take longer, often fifteen minutes or more.

Why I do not add oil or sugar

Recipes often say to add a spoonful of oil if the butter will not loosen. It is not needed. Peanuts are rich in their own oil, and time does what the extra fat would do. The same goes for sugar or syrup: well-roasted peanuts taste sweet and toasty on their own, and many people find their taste adjusts quickly once the sweetened jar is gone.

Please do not add water to thin it. Water makes the butter seize into a stiff paste and shortens how long it keeps. If you want a thinner sauce for a bowl or noodles, stir a little warm water, lime and soy sauce into a spoonful just before you use it.

How to store homemade peanut butter

With nothing added to stabilize it, your peanut butter may separate, with a layer of oil rising to the top. That is normal. Stir it back in.

I would keep it in a clean, closed jar in the fridge, where it lasts a few weeks; use a clean spoon each time. It firms up when cold, so take it out a few minutes before spreading, or keep a small amount in a cupboard if you will finish it within a few days. If it smells sharp, like old paint, or tastes bitter, the oils have turned, and it is time to throw it out.

A word on peanut allergy

Peanuts are one of the nine major food allergens listed by the US Food and Drug Administration, alongside milk, eggs, fish, shellfish, tree nuts, wheat, soybeans and sesame. If you are cooking for other people, ask first, label the jar, and wash the food processor thoroughly before it is used for anyone with an allergy. If you or your child may have a peanut allergy, please talk to your doctor before eating peanuts.

Making it part of the week

Making one jar at the weekend is an easy habit to keep, because it needs no decision during the week. A spoon on an apple is one of my healthy snack ideas for a long gap between meals, and it stirs well into oatmeal or a smoothie. Small, repeated kitchen habits are the kind that last, which is the idea behind how to build good habits. Standing by the processor for ten minutes, watching crumbs turn to butter, is also a good moment to slow down and be present. For guided sessions across the whole method, see Lifetime Body by Design.

A few questions people ask me

Why is my peanut butter not getting creamy? It usually needs more time. Scrape the bowl and keep processing. Cold or under-roasted peanuts also take longer, so warm them in the oven for a few minutes.

Can I use raw peanuts without roasting? You can, but the butter tastes flat and grassy, and it takes longer to turn creamy. Roasting is worth the fifteen minutes.

Can I make it in a blender? A high-speed blender with a tamper can do it with a larger batch. A regular blender usually struggles, so a food processor is the better tool.


There is more from my kitchen under Whole food nutrition, including healthy snack ideas where a spoon of this comes in handy.

This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or dietary advice. Please speak to your doctor or a registered dietitian before making significant changes to how you eat, especially if you have a health condition, a food allergy, or take regular medication.

Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.

Letters from Carol

If this was useful, the letters are where the next one arrives first.

No spam, and you can leave whenever you like. See the privacy page.