
A good balsamic vinaigrette is balsamic vinegar, a little extra virgin olive oil, Dijon mustard, garlic, salt and pepper, shaken in a jar. Most recipes use three parts oil to one part vinegar and add honey or sugar. You need neither. Balsamic vinegar is sweet enough on its own, and a ratio of about one part oil to one part vinegar gives a lighter dressing that still clings to leaves.
I am a wellness coach, and I have eaten whole-food, plant-based for about thirty years, with no meat or dairy. A big salad most days is one of the habits I hold to and teach most often, and a salad is only as good as its dressing. Bottled dressings are where a lot of sugar and seed oil sneaks into an otherwise good plate, so I make my own. This is the one I make when I want something quick and sharp rather than creamy. For the creamy option, see tahini dressing.
Why make your own balsamic dressing
Food is Right Feeding, the second petal of the Starflower, the method in my book, Lifetime Body by Design. The main piece for that petal is how to go plant-based. The idea running through it is simple: eat foods as close to how they grew as you can, and keep the ingredient list short.
Many bottled balsamic dressings list sugar or another syrup near the top, and many use soybean or canola oil instead of olive oil. A homemade version has five or six ingredients you can name, takes five minutes, and keeps for a week. It is one of the easiest swaps I know.
Read the label on the balsamic vinegar
Before the dressing, the vinegar itself. Bottles labeled balsamic vary a great deal. Some contain only cooked grape must and wine vinegar. Others add caramel color, sugar, thickeners or grape must concentrate to make a cheap vinegar taste older and thicker. Balsamic glazes and reductions are often sweetened too.
Turn the bottle over and read the ingredients. The shorter the list, the better. You do not need an expensive bottle for a dressing; a plain, mid-priced balsamic with grape must and wine vinegar on the label works well. If yours is very thin and sharp, a slightly longer shake with the mustard will round it out.
Check the Dijon mustard too. Most list only mustard seed, vinegar, water and salt, but a few add sugar or wine.
How to make balsamic vinaigrette
This makes about ½ cup (120 ml), enough for four to six large salads.
| Ingredient | Amount |
|---|---|
| Balsamic vinegar | ¼ cup (60 ml) |
| Extra virgin olive oil | 3 to 4 tablespoons (45 to 60 ml) |
| Dijon mustard | 1 teaspoon |
| Garlic | 1 small clove, finely grated |
| Water | 1 tablespoon (15 ml) |
| Salt and black pepper | A pinch of each, then to taste |
- Put everything in a clean jar. Grate the garlic straight in so none of it is lost on the board.
- Shake hard for 20 to 30 seconds. The mustard holds the oil and vinegar together, so the dressing turns slightly thick and glossy.
- Taste on a leaf, not a spoon. A dressing always tastes sharper on its own. Add a pinch more salt if it is flat, a little water if it is too sharp.
That is the whole balsamic vinaigrette recipe. It takes about five minutes, most of it finding the jar.
A dressing you made yourself is one less label you have to trust.
A lighter ratio, and why it still works
The classic three-to-one ratio uses a lot of oil for a small bowl of leaves. I keep the oil modest: about one part oil to one part vinegar, sometimes a little less oil. The mustard and the small splash of water carry the dressing, so it still coats the leaves instead of running to the bottom of the bowl.
If you are used to restaurant dressings, this will taste brighter at first. Many people find they prefer it after a week or two, and that the vegetables taste more like themselves.
An oil-free balsamic dressing
For an oil-free version, the mustard needs a little help to give the dressing body. Any one of these works:
- Tahini: 2 teaspoons stirred in with the mustard. Creamy and nutty.
- White beans: 2 tablespoons of cooked white beans, blended with everything else. Thick and mild.
- Aquafaba: 2 tablespoons of the liquid from a can of chickpeas, shaken well. Light and glossy.
- Grated shallot: a tablespoon, finely grated, left to sit in the vinegar for five minutes. Softer and a little sweet.
Use the same amounts of vinegar, mustard, garlic, salt and pepper as above, and add water a spoonful at a time until it pours. The tahini and white bean versions are best blended or whisked rather than shaken.
Easy salad dressing variations
Once the base is in your hands, it changes easily. Each of these starts from the recipe above.
- Herb: add a tablespoon of finely chopped basil, parsley or chives, or a pinch of dried oregano.
- Citrus: swap a tablespoon of the vinegar for orange or lemon juice and add a little grated zest.
- Berry: blend in a small handful of raspberries or strawberries. Sweet from the fruit, no sugar needed.
- Shallot and thyme: add a tablespoon of finely chopped shallot and a few thyme leaves.
Where to use it
Balsamic vinaigrette suits more than lettuce.
- Sturdy greens. It works well on a massaged kale salad, where it soaks in rather than sliding off.
- Tomatoes. Sliced tomatoes, basil, a little salt and a spoon of dressing make a salad in two minutes.
- Roasted vegetables. Toss it through warm roasted beets, squash or roasted cauliflower straight from the oven.
- Beans and grains. A spoon over lentils, white beans or a grain bowl wakes them up.
- A marinade for tofu or mushrooms, left for 20 minutes before roasting.
Storing it
Keep it in a covered jar in the fridge. I use the dressing within about a week, and sooner if it has fresh garlic, shallot, herbs or fruit in it, since those fade first. Olive oil thickens and turns cloudy when cold. That is normal: leave the jar on the counter for ten minutes, or hold it under warm water, then shake again. If it smells off, throw it out.
Making a jar on the same day each week is the kind of small, repeated step I call a Right Action, and repeated actions are how a habit takes root, which is the stem of the Starflower. I wrote more about that in how to build good habits. Five unhurried minutes at the counter also fits the slower pace I describe in slow living. For guided sessions across the whole method, see Lifetime Body by Design.
A few questions people ask me
Why does my vinaigrette separate? Oil and vinegar always separate in time. Mustard slows it down. Shake the jar again before each use.
Is balsamic vinaigrette healthy? That depends on what is in it. Many people find a homemade one with a short ingredient list, little oil and no added sugar an easy way to enjoy more salad. If you have a health condition, ask your doctor or a dietitian what suits you.
Can I use white balsamic? Yes. It is milder and lighter in color, so it is good on pale salads and fruit. Check its label the same way.
Can I make it without mustard? You can, but it will separate faster. A teaspoon of tahini does the same job.
There is more from my kitchen under Whole food nutrition, and if you are just starting out, begin with how to go plant-based.
This article is general information and one person's experience. It is not medical or dietary advice. Please speak to your doctor or a registered dietitian before making significant changes to how you eat.
Carol Pocock is a wellness coach, yoga teacher and the author of Lifetime Body by Design. Guided sessions are at Lifetime Body by Design. More about Carol.
